G’day,
Several fascinating storylines percolated in importance as Carlos Alcaraz and Jannik Sinner battled it out in the 2025 US Open men’s final yesterday. The Spaniard won 6-2, 3-6, 6-1, 6-4, dominating in all facets of the game.
Was it all about the forehands? Or the serve? Or the lack of first serves? Or simply grit and energy?
One key to the final caught my eye in the very first game. Sinner’s opening service game of the match was 12 points long. Sinner missed five first serves and only won one of his five second serve points, to be immediately broken. It was a horror start for Sinner and a dream start for Alcaraz. The match was only a few minutes old, and Alcaraz had firmly seized the momentum.
Sinner’s lack of first serves plagued him in his opening service game and, indeed, for the rest of the final.
Here’s the Italian’s first serve percentage for all seven matches in New York.
Sinner: 1st Serve Percentage (Tournament average = 59%)
- Rd 1 – 59% v Kopriva
- Rd 2 – 51% v Popyrin
- Rd 3 – 58% v Shapovalov
- Rd 4 – 58% v Bublik
- Qtr – 61% v Musetti
- Semi – 53% v Auger-Aliassime
- Final – 48% v Alcaraz
- Average = 54%
The tournament average for first serves in was 59%. That’s down a notch or two over previous years. Sinner was marginally higher than that in only two of his matches. Sinner’s tournament average for first serves in through seven matches was a lowly 54%. That’s basically a failing grade.
EVERYTHING YOU NEED TO KNOW ABOUT SERVING
Webinar 3: Serve Strategy & Patterns
Webinar 34: The 8 Serve Locations
What was wrong with Sinner’s serve? Was it a specific spot he was having trouble with? Yes. It was out wide on both sides.
Here’s Sinner’s 1st serve location in the final and how many times he made it, and also won the point.

Sinner SHOULD be around 70% made to this natural serve location for a right-hander. He was nowhere close, only making 50% of those serves. This was an instant hole in his game in yesterday’s final.

Sinner was marginally better in the Ad court, making 59% of his first serves out wide, which is a favorite first serve location for him. He should be crushing this location.
Combined, Sinner only made 23/42 first serves wide on both sides, which adds up to a lowly 54.7%. That’s not going to get it done against a rampaging Spaniard on the other side of the net.
The real problem here is the “snowball” effect this has on the match. Here’s how that works…
Sinner’s Serve Problems vs Alcaraz
- Problem 1: Only making 48% of first serves.
- Problem 2: Sinner hit 58 2nd serves to only 35 for Alcaraz.
- Problem 3: Sinner only won 48% of 2nd serves to Alcaraz’s 57%.
By the time the fourth set had come around, Sinner was not able to problem-solve his way out of this hole. In fact, it just got deeper. Sinner only made 36% of his first serves in the fourth set. He only made 9/18 first serves out wide on both sides. No chance of a comeback with those numbers.
SUMMARY
There was a lot more to this final than just Sinner’s poor showing with first serves out wide on both sides – and I look forward to analyzing many specific aspects of Alcaraz’s dominant victory.
But you can’t rock up to a Grand Slam final and only make 55% 1st serves out wide on both sides to your preferred targets and expect to get the job done. It pulls your game down and elevates Alcaraz’s at the exact same time.
